This started when I was thinking how most superhero universes are quite crowded.
I began to wonder: suppose I could put any established heroes into a comic book universe, but could use no more than ten, which ones would I choose.
Here's what I came up with:
The Ten-Superhero Universe
1) Superman
Still the template upon which all other superheroes are based. Any good universe needs somebody as the prime heroes are based.
Elements covered:
Ultimate power
Ultimate Goodness
Sci-fi
Alien
Batman
2) The first and biggest major deviation from the Superman mold. Dark where Superman is light, human where Superman is superhuman, he’s managed to eclipse the big guy and may do so for years to come.
Elements covered:
Non-Powered
Dark
Mystery Man
Vigilante
Gadgets
Big Brain
3) Wonder Woman
The natural female counterpart of Superman, with an added mythological angle, she’s a lesser but still indispensable part of a good mythos.
Elements Covered:
Female
Feminist
Mythological
Utopian
4) Spiderman
Belongs because he doesn’t belong. He’s arguably the first, and inarguably the best, misfit hero. His youth also adds a vital element.
Elements Covered:
Young
Witty
Angst-Ridden
5) Iron Man
Okay, He probably would not have made the list without that hit movie, but that’s enough to convince anyone he deserves a spot as the universe’s big brain/tech master, with a suit of armor to go with it. As a real playboy bachelor (as opposed to Bruce Wayne), he adds a unique personality as well.
Elements Covered:
Tech
Big Brain
Armor
Playboy
Businessman
6) Hulk
I considered categorizing him as a supervillain (or more appropriately, foe) of Superman, but his appeal is too big and primal to ignore. He can trade villains with Superman and several others, and his brainy alter ego is a true scientist, unlike Batman’s detective and Iron Man’s engineer.
Elements Covered:
Bruiser
Ultimate Power
Angry
7) Plastic-Man
Maybe no one will ever do him as well as Jack Cole, but his weirdness and humor is indispensible. While Spiderman seems too real a person to be a hero, Plastic Man seems too weird of a superhero to be real.
Elements:
Funny
Weird
Shape-Shifter
8) Zatanna
I really though this was going to be Dr. Strange, my favorite mystical hero, but basically any such character could fill this niche, and Zatanna adds a needed distaff element.
Elements Added:
Female
Light-hearted
Sexy
9) Wolverine
This is a character I honestly do not like very much, but he fills a vital modern niche and makes for good conflict with the “nice” superheroes.
Elements Added:
Mutant
Killer
Savage
International
10) Spawn
Finally, a bit of the macabre. Spawn is probably the best-known example of the surprisingly long list of heroes who got their start by dying (Deadman, The Spectre. Swampt-Thing, etc.) Grim humor, and a lonely quest will give him plenty to do.
Elements Added:
Grim
Supernatural
Pathos
Horror
(Ancillary characters like Supergirl, Robin, Doc Sampson, etc. could also be allowed. And I'd allow ten villains for each hero. But that's for another blog post...)